What is the difference between welding, brazing, and soldering?
The fundamental difference between welding and brazing/soldering is the melting temperature:
Welding:
- The base metal melts — there is local fusion of the assembled pieces
- Temperature: 1,500°C (steel) to 660°C (aluminum)
- High mechanical strength: the joint can reach the strength of the base metal
- Significant thermal expansion, possible distortion
- Requires a certified welder for structural applications
Brazing:
- Only the filler metal melts (above 450°C — this is the very definition of brazing, AWS A3.0); the base metal does not melt
- The joint's mechanical strength is lower than that of the base metal and depends on the filler alloy, the gap between the parts and wettability
- Minimal distortion — ideal for precision assemblies
- Used in plumbing (copper), refrigeration, and electronics
Soldering:
- Temperature below 450°C (definition of soldering, AWS A3.0)
- Used in plumbing (copper pipes with solder) and electronics
- Limited mechanical strength
In Quebec: the acronym QBQ is the label of the preparation offered by Metierium — no official source names a body with that acronym. Welding qualification falls under the real framework: CCQ (certificate issued under the Act respecting pressure vessels, or a CWB certificate), Emploi-Québec for personal qualification, RBQ and ASME IX for company qualification. Brazing in plumbing falls under the CMMTQ: plumbers use a copper-phosphorus alloy for copper piping, with an oxyacetylene or propane torch.